Just wondering, since I've never really heard of him, and he doesn't seem very notable, as it doesn't look like he has much of a following. He also made a page for himself, which is against the wiki's policies.
What's on your mind?
TEXT
POLL
- All56 posts
- General12 posts
- Wiki News and Announcements6 posts
- General Discussion26 posts
- Page notability discussions10 posts
- User rights requests2 posts
Sort by
Card Layout
Page notability discussions
10 Posts
26 Replies
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | Bob and Randy | |
| Reasons: | Series doesn't seem notable enough yet to merit an entire wiki page. Only about 500 views on youtube per video on average and 2 episodes in the series. | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
(Edited by Rioforce)
I can't really fit this into a template because there are so many pages that I am lumping into one deletion topic.
Pages:
- BrothersWaughStudios
- LEGO Batman: Deathstroke
- LEGO Star Wars: Obi-Wan Kenobi VS General Grievous
- LEGO Spider-Man: Crossbones
- LEGO Spiderman: The Cannibals
- LEGO Spider-Man: The Cannibals ENDING
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | (various) | |
| Reasons: | They all violate the wiki rules. First, the films and person aren't notable enough to deserve a wiki page. Second, the creator is creating pages about his own self and films. | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
(Edited by Rioforce)
A decision has been reached.
The voting period has ended and there were in total:
- 2 votes agreeing with the proposal.
- 0 votes disagreeing with the proposal.
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | [[]] | |
| Reasons: | This page doesn't meet formatting standards, and I don't think it is notable enough as from what I can tell, their YouTube channel only has tests or scenes that are unfinished or will be remade. | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
(Edited by Sillypenta)
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | [[]] | |
| Reasons: | This brickfilmer is not well known in the community is not notable enough for a wiki page. | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
(Edited by administrators)
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | [[]] | |
| Reasons: | This video file does not appear to have a page associated with it. In addition the video itself does not appear to particularly notable. It does not seem to have won any competitions be especially well known | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
A decision has been reached.
The voting period has ended and there were in total:
- 3 votes agreeing with the proposal.
- 0 votes disagreeing with the proposal.
As a result this proposal was passed.
The file Lego_spongebob_episode_3_"_Best_Friends%3F" will now be deleted.
(Edited by BoatsAreRockable)
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | [[]] | |
| Reasons: | Christopher Choyce has only created three brickfilms. He won a contest for a local bank, but in my opinion, that is not notable enough to get it's own page. | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
A decision has been reached.
The voting period has ended and there were in total:
- 2 votes agreeing with the proposal.
- 0 votes disagreeing with the proposal.
As a result this proposal was passed.
The Christopher Choyce page will now be deleted.
(Edited by administrators)
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | [[]] | |
| Reasons: | Sorry but I don't think a self-made page can be judged for notability without bias. Even with reasons provided, it is a massive grey area and could be setting a bad precedent. Generally, if someone is notable enough, somebody else is sure to make a page on them in time. | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
(Edited by Sillypenta)
This post is locked.
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | Nikola Bazina | |
| Reasons: | This page appears to be about a relatively new brickfilmer that it quite unknown by the community. I believe here are no sources available to cite this page and think that no one other than the person is question would be able to maintain this page. | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
AGREE
Template:NotabilityResponseLayout
AGREE
Template:NotabilityResponseLayout
AGREE
Template:NotabilityResponseLayout
AGREE
Template:NotabilityResponseLayout
A decision has been reached.
The voting period has ended and there were in total:
- 4 votes agreeing with the proposal.
- 0 votes disagreeing with the proposal.
As a result this proposal was passed.
The Nikola Bazina page will now be deleted.
(Edited by BoatsAreRockable)
This post is locked.
| Type: | Page notability questioned. | |
| Page: | User:BoatsAreRockable/Sandbox1 | |
| Reasons: | This is a test | |
| Respond: | Respond with either AGREE or DISAGREE in capitals. Then on a new line write your reasons. | |
(Edited by BoatsAreRockable)
